• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • NEWS:
  • SatNews
  • SatMagazine
  • MilSatMagazine
  • SmallSat News
  • |     EVENTS:
  • SmallSat Symposium
  • Satellite Innovation
  • MilSat Symposium
  • SmallSat Europe

SatNews

Satellite Industry Intelligence Since 1983

Subscribe
  • LATEST
  • SatNews Events
  • Magazines
  • Calendar
  • Subscribe
  • Missions & Constellations
    • Exploration & Science Missions
    • In-Orbit Servicing & Orbital Operations
    • LEO Constellations
    • Mission Autonomy & Onboard Systems
    • Mission Deployments & Manifests
    • Navigation & PNT
    • SmallSat
    • Spacecraft & Payload Technology
    View All in Missions & Constellations →
    ESA Awards OHB €102 Million Prime Contract for ClearSpace-1 Debris Removal MissionESA Awards OHB €102 Million Prime Contract for ClearSpace-1 Debris Removal Mission
    Google Selects Blue Origin’s New Glenn Rocket for 2029 AI Satellite LaunchGoogle Selects Blue Origin’s New Glenn Rocket for 2029 AI Satellite Launch
    RBC Signals Secures $10 Million Strategic Growth Investment Led by Washington Harbour PartnersRBC Signals Secures $10 Million Strategic Growth Investment Led by Washington Harbour Partners
    GomSpace Secures €8 Million Phase 2 Contract for North American Dual-Satellite Lunar Prospecting MissionGomSpace Secures €8 Million Phase 2 Contract for North American Dual-Satellite Lunar Prospecting Mission
  • Business
    • Contracts & Commercial Deals
    • Earnings & Financial Reporting
    • Events & Conferences
    • Funding & Venture Capital
    • Market Forecasts
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Personnel Moves & Appointments
    View All in Business & Finance →
    Telesat Secures Six-Week Debt Standstill From GEO Lenders Through Jan. 18, 2027Telesat Secures Six-Week Debt Standstill From GEO Lenders Through Jan. 18, 2027
    SES Targets Middle Corridor and Central Asia Amid €623 Million EU Infrastructure PushSES Targets Middle Corridor and Central Asia Amid €623 Million EU Infrastructure Push
    PLD Space Signs First Commercial MIURA 5 Launch Contract With Mitsubishi ElectricPLD Space Signs First Commercial MIURA 5 Launch Contract With Mitsubishi Electric
    Iceye Makes All-Cash €2 Billion ($2.2B) Takeover Offer for Italian Rocket Builder AvioIceye Makes All-Cash €2 Billion ($2.2B) Takeover Offer for Italian Rocket Builder Avio
  • Defense
    • Counterspace & ASAT
    • Defense Budgets & Procurement
    • ISR & Reconnaissance
    • MILSATCOM
    • Missile Warning & Defense
    • National Security Programs
    • Space Domain Awareness
    View All in Military & Defense →
    Senate Appropriators Move to Bar Sole-Source Awards Over $100 Million for Space Data Network and SB-AMTISenate Appropriators Move to Bar Sole-Source Awards Over $100 Million for Space Data Network and SB-AMTI
    Space Force Awards $10 Million in SEWOL Prototype Contracts to Three FirmsSpace Force Awards $10 Million in SEWOL Prototype Contracts to Three Firms
    York Space Systems Posts $807.4M Q3 Loss After $749.7M Pentagon Contract ChargeYork Space Systems Posts $807.4M Q3 Loss After $749.7M Pentagon Contract Charge
    Ukraine Reports Renewed Starshield Velocity Restrictions on Military DronesUkraine Reports Renewed Starshield Velocity Restrictions on Military Drones
  • Gov
    • Export Controls & Compliance
    • International Space Agreements
    • National Space Policy
    • Space Law & Treaties
    • Space Sustainability & Debris Policy
    • Space Traffic Management / Debris Removal
    View All in Government & Regulation →
    FCC Upper C-Band Auction 115 Creates Indirect Spectrum and Market Shifts for SmallSat and LEO OperatorsFCC Upper C-Band Auction 115 Creates Indirect Spectrum and Market Shifts for SmallSat and LEO Operators
    FCC Sets April 27, 2027 Start Date for Upper C-Band Auction, Pressuring BroadcastersFCC Sets April 27, 2027 Start Date for Upper C-Band Auction, Pressuring Broadcasters
    Starlink Satellites Pass Over South Africa, But Licensing Approval Remains StalledStarlink Satellites Pass Over South Africa, But Licensing Approval Remains Stalled
    Satellogic Reports Record Revenue and Largest-Ever $37 Million Sovereign Satellite OrderSatellogic Reports Record Revenue and Largest-Ever $37 Million Sovereign Satellite Order
  • Launch
    • Launch Providers
    • Launch Schedule & Calendars
    • Launch Sites & Infrastructure
    • Rocket Technology & Vehicles
    View All in Launch →
    ULA Clears Blue Origin BE-4 Engines, Focuses Vulcan Failure Probe on Core Stage Fuel SupplyULA Clears Blue Origin BE-4 Engines, Focuses Vulcan Failure Probe on Core Stage Fuel Supply
    NASA’s Voyager 1 Reaches One Light-Day From Earth at 16.1 Billion MilesNASA’s Voyager 1 Reaches One Light-Day From Earth at 16.1 Billion Miles
    Southern Launch Recovers Second Varda Space Capsule in 12 Days at Koonibba Test RangeSouthern Launch Recovers Second Varda Space Capsule in 12 Days at Koonibba Test Range
    Nammo UK Completes Prototype Hot-Fire Tests for ESA Argonaut Lunar Lander EngineNammo UK Completes Prototype Hot-Fire Tests for ESA Argonaut Lunar Lander Engine
  • Software
    • Autonomous Ground Operations
    • Data Processing & AI/ML
    • Digital Twins & Modeling
    • Ground Segment & Teleports
    • Mission Planning & Simulation
    • Space Systems Software Engineering
    • Spectrum & Licensing
    View All in Software Automation & Ground Systems →
    Ramon.Space Raises $124 Million Series B to Scale Orbital Computing InfrastructureRamon.Space Raises $124 Million Series B to Scale Orbital Computing Infrastructure
    Gilat Cuts 2026 Growth Forecast to 3% Amid Launch and IFC DelaysGilat Cuts 2026 Growth Forecast to 3% Amid Launch and IFC Delays
    U.S. Navy Expands ALL.SPACE Terminal Fleet to 108 with Follow-On Hydra MAX 2 OrderU.S. Navy Expands ALL.SPACE Terminal Fleet to 108 with Follow-On Hydra MAX 2 Order
    SpaceX Selects Qualcomm to Supply Terrestrial Base Stations for Starlink Mobile NetworkSpaceX Selects Qualcomm to Supply Terrestrial Base Stations for Starlink Mobile Network
  • Services & Apps
    • Climate & Environmental Monitoring
    • Disaster Response & Security Mapping
    • Earth Observation & Imaging
    • Maritime & Aviation Satcom
    • Satellite Communications
    View All in Services & Applications →
    Thales Alenia Space Awarded DGA Contract for French IRIS Military Optical ConstellationThales Alenia Space Awarded DGA Contract for French IRIS Military Optical Constellation
    Ubotica Demonstrates Autonomous Onboard Satellite Scheduling for Maritime SurveillanceUbotica Demonstrates Autonomous Onboard Satellite Scheduling for Maritime Surveillance
    UniSQ Demonstrates Tomographic Spectrometer During KREPE-3 Re-Entry CampaignUniSQ Demonstrates Tomographic Spectrometer During KREPE-3 Re-Entry Campaign
    MDA Space Secures C$100M+ Thales Alenia Space Award for First 66 IRIS² SatellitesMDA Space Secures C$100M+ Thales Alenia Space Award for First 66 IRIS² Satellites

Is It Terminal? Mess Threatens DoD SATCOM Multi-Domain

January 9, 2020

WASHINGTON: The third GPS III satellite sporting the jam-proof, spoof-proof military signal called M-Code is due to be launched next month. Sadly, troops won’t be able to use that encrypted signal until at least 2021 (if then, given the program’s history of delays) because there aren’t any receivers for it yet fielded.

Even though satellite communications are critical to future multi-domain operations (MDO), the Pentagon seems incapable of fixing long-standing problems with ground terminals and mobile receivers that stop users in the field and weapons platforms from communicating efficiently.

What’s the problem? Some satellite terminals/receivers link to only one frequency or one type of satellite; ships and Humvees use outdated terminals that would be too expensive to replace; and sometimes new satellites end up orbiting the Earth for years without any users because the terminals to make them useful weren’t built on time. (For example, the first Navy’s Mobile Objective User System, or MUOS, satellite was launched in 2012 and the constellation of five sats was declared fully operational in November, but according to GAO “the user community still cannot monitor and manage MUOS.”)

“Satellite communications is like the air we breathe. Absent that inherent capability, missions cannot be executed, whatever that mission may be,” says Rebecca Cowen-Hirsch, senior vice president for government strategy and policy at Inmarsat Government.

As Breaking D readers know, satellite communications are central to the Pentagon’s vision for Joint All Domain Command and Control (JADC2), which in turn is central to enabling the MDO strategy and allowing linkages across all five domains of warfare (air, land, sea, space and cyber) and integrating all sensors with all shooters.

But DoD lacks a coherent strategy for acquiring satcom terminals necessary to access even its own military satellites, as the Government Accountability Office (GAO) reported in its December 19 review of the Pentagon’s June 2018 analysis of alternatives (AoA) for optimizing wideband satellite communications.

“The sheer number and types of wideband terminals DOD currently uses presents a very large challenge for changing how DoD acquires wideband SATCOM capabilities,” GAO’s Cristina Chaplain told me. “Additionally, DoD faces questions on how to govern terminal acquisitions, which currently take place in many programs spread across the services.”

DoD currently maintains 17,000 terminals that use “approximately 135 different designs,” GAO said. Those terminals operate across diverse platforms—such as ships, backpacks, vehicles — and all have differing system requirements. Many can talk to only one type of satellite. Further, while the Air Force builds satellites, terminals/receivers are usually bought by the service or command that will use the data — resulting in mismatches in timing.

GAO warned that “both our past work and the Wideband AoA found that DoD faces ongoing risks in aligning its satellite and ground control systems.”

DoD “officials estimate spending an average of $4 billion each year to acquire and sustain wideband satellite communications capabilities, including developing and fielding military satellite systems, contracting for commercial satellite communications services, and acquiring and operating satellite ground terminals,” GAO said. Note the word estimate, because in reality the Pentagon doesn’t quite have its arms around current satcom usage by the services and combatant commands — all of which have their fingers in the satcom acquisition pie.

Wideband communications satellites provide DoD with fast and reliable voice, video, and data communications to support critical military operations around the globe. Wideband satellites operate in different radio frequency spectrum bands. DoD typically relies on C, X, Ku, and Ka-bands to provide wideband connectivity, depending on where and how users are operating.

Each of these frequency bands has advantages and disadvantages for various applications. Satellite transponders operating at the lower C-band frequencies are more robust, especially when it rains (water degrades some RF signals.) Under US law, X-band usage is limited to the US government and NATO. The Ku-band can communicate with smaller antennas and is useful for mobile operations. Ka-band satellites can transmit more data, including high-speed video, than satellites using the other frequencies, but their signals are more susceptible to rain and fog.

Commercial satcom providers traditionally have used the Ku-band, but many are now expanding services to Ka-band to offer customers higher data rates.


Boeing WGS

Boeing WGS

Currently, DoD relies on the aging Wideband Global SATCOM (WGS) system for much of its milcoms, along with buying commercial satellite bandwidth on a piecemeal basis. The WGS satellites, built by Boeing, can provide full-motion video in the Ka- and X-bands. There are 10 in the current constellation, and Congress in 2018 added funds for two more, overturning Air Force plans to stop procurement.

Boeing announced on Dec. 26 that it has completed development of WGS 11, to be delivered to the Air Force in 2024. According to the company, this new satellite will “deliver hundreds of coverage beams and provide a more flexible and efficient use of bandwidth. These innovations will enable the spacecraft to support more users in theater and allow dedicated beams to follow aircraft in flight.”

And, as I reported in October, Gen. Jay Raymond, head of SPACECOM and at the time also head of Air Force Space Command, is mulling a new SATCOM Enterprise Vision.That effort is aimed at creating a seamless network of military and commercial communications satellites in all orbits, accessible to troops, vehicles, ships and aircraft via ground terminals and mobile receivers that would automatically “hop” from one satellite network to another.

In addition, “DoD concluded in the Wideband AoA that integrating purpose-built satellite systems and commercially provided systems into a hybrid architecture would be more cost effective and capable than any single purpose-built or commercial system alone,” the GAO report said.

As Breaking D readers know, major commercial satcom providers, such as Inmarsat, have been pushing DoD to move toward buying so-called “managed services” (kinda like your average mobile phone or cable TV/Internet plan) rather than leasing commercial bandwidth in fits and starts for short periods of time. This, they argue, will substantially reduce the high costs of pay-as-you-go rental of commercial bandwidth.


Inmarsat GX

Inmarsat GX satellite

Congress has agreed with this argument, and included $49.5 million in the 2019 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for DoD to pursue commercial satcom-as-a-service acquisition. However, DoD has been slow to allocate the funds as it continues to study the broader issues, and did not request new funding in 2020. Congress, however, forced another $5 million into Air Force’s budget for commercial satcom service buys in the 2020 NDAA. 

Indeed, the AoA study determined that DoD needs more information about industry capabilities before pulling the trigger on buying satcom as a service. The AoA also found that buying new terminals to work with commercial systems can be expensive, due to development and integration costs.

One of the cost-drivers is that vehicles like Humvees or ships have maintenance periods that are scheduled years in advance. Thus, putting in new satcom terminals can require unscheduled maintenance that incurs not just direct costs, but also indirect costs in personnel and mission delays.

At the same time, the GAO report explains that a separate DoD study found that some terminals can be modified to operate with more types of satellites by adding new modems or software, thus reducing replacement costs. “This capability, aligned with regular terminal recapitalization schedules, can help improve terminal affordability, according to officials,” the GAO report said.

GAO welcomed the Wideband SATCOM AoA recommendation that DoD develop an “Enterprise Satellite Communications Terminal Strategy” to “reduce complexity of terminal diversity and governance; facilitate rapid modernization through flexible terminals that can use new waveforms; and optimize cost, schedule, performance, and interoperability.”

But, the watchdog agency worries, the Pentagon does not yet have a plan for implementing the AoA’s findings. One key concern is that the ongoing musical chairs regarding space acquisition is complicating decision-making. This includes the establishment of Space Command, the launch of the Space Development Agency and the new Space Force.

By Theresa Hitchens, BreakingDefense

Filed Under: MILSATCOM, Space Systems Software Engineering

Primary Sidebar

Coverage

  • Missions & Constellations
  • Business & Finance
  • Military & Defense
  • Launch
  • Software Automation & Ground Systems
  • Government & Regulation
  • Services & Applications

Most Read Stories

  • Space Force Reassigns Six National Security Launches to SpaceX Amid Vulcan Grounding
  • Blue Origin Reconstructs Launch Complex 36 Tower, Targets November Return to Flight for New Glenn
  • Xona Space Systems Secures $250M Series D at $2.45B Valuation to Scale Pulsar PNT Fleet
  • Amazon Navigates Launch Delays with Under 400 Satellites in Orbit Ahead of Nov. 13 Vulcan Return
  • Starlink Surges to 13.6 Million Subscribers as GSMA Assesses TAM Penetration and Telco Defense

Secondary Sidebar

Footer

 

Satnews is a leading provider of satellite news, events, publications, research and other satellite industry information in both commercial and military enterprises worldwide.

Stories By Category

  • Business & Finance
  • Government & Regulation
  • Launch
  • Military & Defense
  • Missions & Constellations
  • Services & Applications
  • Software Automation & Ground Systems
  • Spectrum & Licensing
  • Startups & NewSpace Business

About Us

  • Leadership & Editorial Team
  • SatNews History
  • Free Satnews Subscription
  • SatNews Events
  • Magazines

Navigation

  • Latest Stories
  • Magazines
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Cookie & Privacy Policy for Satnews

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.
x
Sign up Now (For Free)
Access daily or weekly satellite news updates covering all aspects of the commercial and military satellite industry.
Invalid email address
We value your privacy and will not sell or share your email or other information with any other company. You may also unsubscribe at anytime.

Click Here to see our full privacy policy.
Thanks for subscribing!