• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • NEWS:
  • SatNews
  • SatMagazine
  • MilSatMagazine
  • SmallSat News
  • |     EVENTS:
  • SmallSat Symposium
  • Satellite Innovation
  • MilSat Symposium
  • SmallSat Europe

SatNews

Satellite Industry Intelligence Since 1983

Subscribe
  • LATEST
  • SatNews Events
  • Magazines
  • Calendar
  • Subscribe
  • Missions & Constellations
    • Exploration & Science Missions
    • In-Orbit Servicing & Orbital Operations
    • LEO Constellations
    • Mission Autonomy & Onboard Systems
    • Mission Deployments & Manifests
    • Navigation & PNT
    • SmallSat
    • Spacecraft & Payload Technology
    View All in Missions & Constellations →
    FCC Upper C-Band Auction 115 Creates Indirect Spectrum and Market Shifts for SmallSat and LEO OperatorsFCC Upper C-Band Auction 115 Creates Indirect Spectrum and Market Shifts for SmallSat and LEO Operators
    PLD Space Signs First Commercial MIURA 5 Launch Contract With Mitsubishi ElectricPLD Space Signs First Commercial MIURA 5 Launch Contract With Mitsubishi Electric
    Southern Launch Recovers Second Varda Space Capsule in 12 Days at Koonibba Test RangeSouthern Launch Recovers Second Varda Space Capsule in 12 Days at Koonibba Test Range
    Iceye Makes All-Cash €2 Billion ($2.2B) Takeover Offer for Italian Rocket Builder AvioIceye Makes All-Cash €2 Billion ($2.2B) Takeover Offer for Italian Rocket Builder Avio
  • Business
    • Contracts & Commercial Deals
    • Earnings & Financial Reporting
    • Events & Conferences
    • Funding & Venture Capital
    • Market Forecasts
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Personnel Moves & Appointments
    View All in Business & Finance →
    Ramon.Space Raises $124 Million Series B to Scale Orbital Computing InfrastructureRamon.Space Raises $124 Million Series B to Scale Orbital Computing Infrastructure
    Satellogic Reports Record Revenue and Largest-Ever $37 Million Sovereign Satellite OrderSatellogic Reports Record Revenue and Largest-Ever $37 Million Sovereign Satellite Order
    Thales Alenia Space Signs ESA Contract Amendments to Advance TeQuantS Quantum Satellite ProjectThales Alenia Space Signs ESA Contract Amendments to Advance TeQuantS Quantum Satellite Project
    Serco Agrees to Acquire QinetiQ’s U.S. Operations for $292 MillionSerco Agrees to Acquire QinetiQ’s U.S. Operations for $292 Million
  • Defense
    • Counterspace & ASAT
    • Defense Budgets & Procurement
    • ISR & Reconnaissance
    • MILSATCOM
    • Missile Warning & Defense
    • National Security Programs
    • Space Domain Awareness
    View All in Military & Defense →
    Senate Appropriators Move to Bar Sole-Source Awards Over $100 Million for Space Data Network and SB-AMTISenate Appropriators Move to Bar Sole-Source Awards Over $100 Million for Space Data Network and SB-AMTI
    Space Force Awards $10 Million in SEWOL Prototype Contracts to Three FirmsSpace Force Awards $10 Million in SEWOL Prototype Contracts to Three Firms
    York Space Systems Posts $807.4M Q3 Loss After $749.7M Pentagon Contract ChargeYork Space Systems Posts $807.4M Q3 Loss After $749.7M Pentagon Contract Charge
    Ukraine Reports Renewed Starshield Velocity Restrictions on Military DronesUkraine Reports Renewed Starshield Velocity Restrictions on Military Drones
  • Gov
    • Export Controls & Compliance
    • International Space Agreements
    • National Space Policy
    • Space Law & Treaties
    • Space Sustainability & Debris Policy
    • Space Traffic Management / Debris Removal
    View All in Government & Regulation →
    FCC Sets April 27, 2027 Start Date for Upper C-Band Auction, Pressuring BroadcastersFCC Sets April 27, 2027 Start Date for Upper C-Band Auction, Pressuring Broadcasters
    Starlink Satellites Pass Over South Africa, But Licensing Approval Remains StalledStarlink Satellites Pass Over South Africa, But Licensing Approval Remains Stalled
    Space42 and Viasat Clear Regulatory Hurdle for 2,800-Satellite Equatys D2D VentureSpace42 and Viasat Clear Regulatory Hurdle for 2,800-Satellite Equatys D2D Venture
    France Approves Globalstar to Launch 54 Next-Gen D2D Satellites Under 20-Year Spectrum LicenseFrance Approves Globalstar to Launch 54 Next-Gen D2D Satellites Under 20-Year Spectrum License
  • Launch
    • Launch Providers
    • Launch Schedule & Calendars
    • Launch Sites & Infrastructure
    • Rocket Technology & Vehicles
    View All in Launch →
    Nammo UK Completes Prototype Hot-Fire Tests for ESA Argonaut Lunar Lander EngineNammo UK Completes Prototype Hot-Fire Tests for ESA Argonaut Lunar Lander Engine
    Rocket Lab Completes 100th Electron Launch With 11th Mission for iQPSRocket Lab Completes 100th Electron Launch With 11th Mission for iQPS
    ULA Vulcan Centaur Suffers Anomaly During Return to Flight, Losing 40 Amazon Leo SatellitesULA Vulcan Centaur Suffers Anomaly During Return to Flight, Losing 40 Amazon Leo Satellites
    AST SpaceMobile Details Blacklift Rocket Vision Amid Commercial Launch CrunchAST SpaceMobile Details Blacklift Rocket Vision Amid Commercial Launch Crunch
  • Software
    • Autonomous Ground Operations
    • Data Processing & AI/ML
    • Digital Twins & Modeling
    • Ground Segment & Teleports
    • Mission Planning & Simulation
    • Space Systems Software Engineering
    • Spectrum & Licensing
    View All in Software Automation & Ground Systems →
    Gilat Cuts 2026 Growth Forecast to 3% Amid Launch and IFC DelaysGilat Cuts 2026 Growth Forecast to 3% Amid Launch and IFC Delays
    U.S. Navy Expands ALL.SPACE Terminal Fleet to 108 with Follow-On Hydra MAX 2 OrderU.S. Navy Expands ALL.SPACE Terminal Fleet to 108 with Follow-On Hydra MAX 2 Order
    SpaceX Selects Qualcomm to Supply Terrestrial Base Stations for Starlink Mobile NetworkSpaceX Selects Qualcomm to Supply Terrestrial Base Stations for Starlink Mobile Network
    Northwood Space Secures $375M Series C at $2B Valuation to Expand Shared Ground Station NetworkNorthwood Space Secures $375M Series C at $2B Valuation to Expand Shared Ground Station Network
  • Services & Apps
    • Climate & Environmental Monitoring
    • Disaster Response & Security Mapping
    • Earth Observation & Imaging
    • Maritime & Aviation Satcom
    • Satellite Communications
    View All in Services & Applications →
    Thales Alenia Space Awarded DGA Contract for French IRIS Military Optical ConstellationThales Alenia Space Awarded DGA Contract for French IRIS Military Optical Constellation
    Ubotica Demonstrates Autonomous Onboard Satellite Scheduling for Maritime SurveillanceUbotica Demonstrates Autonomous Onboard Satellite Scheduling for Maritime Surveillance
    UniSQ Demonstrates Tomographic Spectrometer During KREPE-3 Re-Entry CampaignUniSQ Demonstrates Tomographic Spectrometer During KREPE-3 Re-Entry Campaign
    MDA Space Secures C$100M+ Thales Alenia Space Award for First 66 IRIS² SatellitesMDA Space Secures C$100M+ Thales Alenia Space Award for First 66 IRIS² Satellites

UPDATE: MEASAT vs. Intelsat Dispute… In The United States District Court…(Legal)

May 14, 2012

[SatNews] Filed on April 27, 2012, in the United States District Court, Central District of California, Los Angeles, is a lawsuit by…

MEASAT Satellite Systems BHD against Intelsat Corporation. The Case Number is VC12-03702.The complaint lists breach of contract that was memorialized on or about March 9, 2006, when MEASAT and Intelsat entered into the written contract for Land Launch and Program Management Services relating to the launch of the MEASAT 1R satellite, which was to cost $40,250,000, which MEASAT contests was the flat and fixed and total fee due, witih no additional funds due prior to or after the launch.

Launch services were to be provided by Sea Launch as a subcontractor to Intelsat; however, there were then issues regarding launch delays—MEASAT contends they were unable to secure a launch date due to an insufficient number of rocket motors available to meet the government launch requirements and its commercial schedule. As a result, Sea Launch experienced delays in the conversion of its rocket control systems from a sea launch vehicle to the land launch vehicle.

In January 2008, the two companies negotiated and agreed to a revised launch slot from August 1st through the 31st, 2008.

MEASAT caused the satellite’s manufacturer, Orbital Sciences, to deliver the satellite to the Baikonur Launch Facility, on or about July 23, 2008, for combined launch operations to start August 6; however, just days before the scheduled launch, MEASAT’s launch was derailed when a subcontractor struck the satellite with a crane, which caused extensive damage to the satellite. Hence, the satellite was returned to the manufacturer for repairs and testing.

In order to repair the damage, MEASAT arranged to have the satellite transported back to its manufacturer for repairs and tests. Incredibly, the satellite was damaged again, when Sea Launch and/or an SIS subcontractor dropped the satellite six feet while trying to load the satellite into the airplane cargo hatch using a crane.

The race was on to return the satellite to Orbital for testing, repair and return in order for the process to start again for a launch. Subsequently, MEASAT incurred financial issues wherein the loan facilities’ agreement were not in compliance with an acceptable debt ratio.

MEASAT contests that the delays each month cost them millions of dollars in lost revenues. Additionally, MEASAT was unable to meet the capacity growth requirements for its C- and Ku-band customers, forcing them to prioritize its limited capacity allocation to low-rate paying Malaysian telecom customers.

This is an abbreviated timeline condensed from the complaint document that is available for public review. The remainder of the issues are primarily focused around accusations of delays and expenses that were not part of the original agreement.

MEASAT is suing for economic duress, unjust enrichment, breach of the convent of good faith and fair dealing, and, lastly, a violation of California Business and Professions Code §17200. There is also a demand for a jury trial. Referred to as the causative reason for the lawsuit is a breach of satellite launch contract for MEASAT 1R, with Sea Launch named as a co-conspirator. Being sought are damages in the amount of $29,000,000 as well as punitive damages, attorneys’ fees and costs of the suit, and other relief as the “Court will deem just, equitable and proper.”

According to the filing, Intelsat had been fully paid for the launch by MEASAT; however, the filing states that Intelsat demanded MEASAT make an additional $4.5 million payment as well as a release of all claims associated with the damage to the MEASAT satellite and the resulting launch delays. If such was not to be approved by Intelsat, the filing states no launch of the MEASAT satellite would occur and Intelsat would acquire the launch slot for its own uses. The complaint then stipulates MEASAT paid the $4.5 million under duress and provided the demanded releases in order to ensure the Company secured the already paid for launch slot. MEASAT paid a firm fixed price of $40,250,000 as the total amount due for the bargained-for satellite launch, and there were no terms within the agreement to pay any additional funds, either preceding, or after, the launch.

Various other incidents caused damage to the MEASAT satellite and are addressed in the filing papers. Requests for comments on this filing were placed at both the plaintiff’s legal offices of Jones Day in Los Angeles, California, and with Intelsat’s legal department in Washington, DC.

Calls to both Jones Day and Intelsat required voicemail messages be left. As of this writing, no comments from the parties have been received. We shall update this news item when, and if, such are received.

UPDATE: Intelsat’s Dianne VanBeber, Vice President of Investor Relations and Corporate Communications returned our call and stated, “We’re still in the early stages of reviewing the claim, but we do not presently believe that a litigation will be material to our business.”

Filed Under: Space Law & Treaties

Primary Sidebar

Coverage

  • Missions & Constellations
  • Business & Finance
  • Military & Defense
  • Launch
  • Software Automation & Ground Systems
  • Government & Regulation
  • Services & Applications

Most Read Stories

  • Space Force Reassigns Six National Security Launches to SpaceX Amid Vulcan Grounding
  • Blue Origin Reconstructs Launch Complex 36 Tower, Targets November Return to Flight for New Glenn
  • Xona Space Systems Secures $250M Series D at $2.45B Valuation to Scale Pulsar PNT Fleet
  • Amazon Navigates Launch Delays with Under 400 Satellites in Orbit Ahead of Nov. 13 Vulcan Return
  • Planet Labs Launches Pelican-12 Aboard SpaceX Bandwagon-5 to Test Orbital AI and Satellite Relays

Secondary Sidebar

Footer

 

Satnews is a leading provider of satellite news, events, publications, research and other satellite industry information in both commercial and military enterprises worldwide.

Stories By Category

  • Business & Finance
  • Government & Regulation
  • Launch
  • Military & Defense
  • Missions & Constellations
  • Services & Applications
  • Software Automation & Ground Systems
  • Spectrum & Licensing
  • Startups & NewSpace Business

About Us

  • Leadership & Editorial Team
  • SatNews History
  • Free Satnews Subscription
  • SatNews Events
  • Magazines

Navigation

  • Latest Stories
  • Magazines
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Cookie & Privacy Policy for Satnews

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.
x
Sign up Now (For Free)
Access daily or weekly satellite news updates covering all aspects of the commercial and military satellite industry.
Invalid email address
Notify Me Regarding ( At least one ):
We value your privacy and will not sell or share your email or other information with any other company. You may also unsubscribe at anytime.

Click Here to see our full privacy policy.
Thanks for subscribing!