• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • NEWS:
  • SatNews
  • SatMagazine
  • MilSatMagazine
  • SmallSat News
  • |     EVENTS:
  • SmallSat Symposium
  • Satellite Innovation
  • MilSat Symposium
  • SmallSat Europe

SatNews

Satellite Industry Intelligence Since 1983

Subscribe
  • LATEST
  • SatNews Events
  • Magazines
  • Calendar
  • Subscribe
  • Missions & Constellations
    • Exploration & Science Missions
    • In-Orbit Servicing & Orbital Operations
    • LEO Constellations
    • Mission Autonomy & Onboard Systems
    • Mission Deployments & Manifests
    • Navigation & PNT
    • SmallSat
    • Spacecraft & Payload Technology
    View All in Missions & Constellations →
    AST SpaceMobile Unveils Blacklift Rocket Under $1.3B Firefly Engine AgreementAST SpaceMobile Unveils Blacklift Rocket Under $1.3B Firefly Engine Agreement
    CesiumAstro Secures $730M Series D at $4.5B Valuation to Deploy Synchronicity ConstellationCesiumAstro Secures $730M Series D at $4.5B Valuation to Deploy Synchronicity Constellation
    Pentagon Commits $150M OSC Loan to LeoLabs in $300M Radar Network ExpansionPentagon Commits $150M OSC Loan to LeoLabs in $300M Radar Network Expansion
    Redwire Wins $20M DARPA Contract for Scaled SabreSat VLEO Precursor FlightRedwire Wins $20M DARPA Contract for Scaled SabreSat VLEO Precursor Flight
  • Business
    • Contracts & Commercial Deals
    • Earnings & Financial Reporting
    • Events & Conferences
    • Funding & Venture Capital
    • Market Forecasts
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Personnel Moves & Appointments
    View All in Business & Finance →
    SES Posts 4.2% Q3 Growth Driven by Defense Contracts and Books 53 Satellites Through 2030SES Posts 4.2% Q3 Growth Driven by Defense Contracts and Books 53 Satellites Through 2030
    SpaceX Selects Qualcomm to Supply Terrestrial Base Stations for Starlink Mobile NetworkSpaceX Selects Qualcomm to Supply Terrestrial Base Stations for Starlink Mobile Network
    SpaceX Explores Boost Mobile Acquisition in Push to Build Hybrid Terrestrial-Satellite NetworkSpaceX Explores Boost Mobile Acquisition in Push to Build Hybrid Terrestrial-Satellite Network
    MDA Space Secures C$100M+ Thales Alenia Space Award for First 66 IRIS² SatellitesMDA Space Secures C$100M+ Thales Alenia Space Award for First 66 IRIS² Satellites
  • Defense
    • Counterspace & ASAT
    • Defense Budgets & Procurement
    • ISR & Reconnaissance
    • MILSATCOM
    • Missile Warning & Defense
    • National Security Programs
    • Space Domain Awareness
    View All in Military & Defense →
    ThinKom and Space Systems Command Demonstrate GECKO Multi-Orbit Containerized SATCOM SystemThinKom and Space Systems Command Demonstrate GECKO Multi-Orbit Containerized SATCOM System
    Vantor Cuts Satellite Imagery Delivery Time to Seven Minutes in Ukrainian Field DemonstrationVantor Cuts Satellite Imagery Delivery Time to Seven Minutes in Ukrainian Field Demonstration
    L3Harris Secures $36M Army SATCOM Order for Hawkeye 4 Lite Terminals Supporting C2NOWL3Harris Secures $36M Army SATCOM Order for Hawkeye 4 Lite Terminals Supporting C2NOW
    Space Force Awards Lockheed Martin $95M GPS IIIF Modification, Bringing Contract Face Value to $4.73BSpace Force Awards Lockheed Martin $95M GPS IIIF Modification, Bringing Contract Face Value to $4.73B
  • Gov
    • Export Controls & Compliance
    • International Space Agreements
    • National Space Policy
    • Space Law & Treaties
    • Space Sustainability & Debris Policy
    • Space Traffic Management / Debris Removal
    View All in Government & Regulation →
    Globalstar Petitions FCC to Scrutinize Rocket Lab Supplier Conflict Over $8B Iridium DealGlobalstar Petitions FCC to Scrutinize Rocket Lab Supplier Conflict Over $8B Iridium Deal
    Russia Files ITU Plan for 374-Satellite Rassvet-4 Constellation Following Rassvet-3 Orbital SetbacksRussia Files ITU Plan for 374-Satellite Rassvet-4 Constellation Following Rassvet-3 Orbital Setbacks
    FCC Proposes 25 MHz Mid-Band Spectrum Auction with Dual 5G and Direct-to-Device AllocationsFCC Proposes 25 MHz Mid-Band Spectrum Auction with Dual 5G and Direct-to-Device Allocations
    Part 100 Puts FCC Satellite Licensing on an Assembly LinePart 100 Puts FCC Satellite Licensing on an Assembly Line
  • Launch
    • Launch Providers
    • Launch Schedule & Calendars
    • Launch Sites & Infrastructure
    • Rocket Technology & Vehicles
    View All in Launch →
    Amazon Navigates Launch Delays with Under 400 Satellites in Orbit Ahead of Nov. 13 Vulcan ReturnAmazon Navigates Launch Delays with Under 400 Satellites in Orbit Ahead of Nov. 13 Vulcan Return
    NASA Outlines Artemis IV Starship Refueling Architecture as Launch Estimates VaryNASA Outlines Artemis IV Starship Refueling Architecture as Launch Estimates Vary
    HIMERA and GomSpace Begin Orbital Operations of OBRIA NANO Test Satellite for Sovereign Ukrainian NetworkHIMERA and GomSpace Begin Orbital Operations of OBRIA NANO Test Satellite for Sovereign Ukrainian Network
    Blue Origin Reconstructs Launch Complex 36 Tower, Targets November Return to Flight for New GlennBlue Origin Reconstructs Launch Complex 36 Tower, Targets November Return to Flight for New Glenn
  • Software
    • Autonomous Ground Operations
    • Data Processing & AI/ML
    • Digital Twins & Modeling
    • Ground Segment & Teleports
    • Mission Planning & Simulation
    • Space Systems Software Engineering
    • Spectrum & Licensing
    View All in Software Automation & Ground Systems →
    Northwood Space Secures $375M Series C at $2B Valuation to Expand Shared Ground Station NetworkNorthwood Space Secures $375M Series C at $2B Valuation to Expand Shared Ground Station Network
    MBSat Selects ST Engineering iDirect Intuition Platform for Ground Infrastructure in OmanMBSat Selects ST Engineering iDirect Intuition Platform for Ground Infrastructure in Oman
    AnySignal Co-Founder Urges Ground Station Interoperability to Resolve Orbital Data BottlenecksAnySignal Co-Founder Urges Ground Station Interoperability to Resolve Orbital Data Bottlenecks
    Arqiva Secures Three-Year Satellite Services Agreement with Kuwait’s GulfsatArqiva Secures Three-Year Satellite Services Agreement with Kuwait’s Gulfsat
  • Services & Apps
    • Climate & Environmental Monitoring
    • Disaster Response & Security Mapping
    • Earth Observation & Imaging
    • Maritime & Aviation Satcom
    • Satellite Communications
    View All in Services & Applications →
    Ubotica Demonstrates Autonomous Onboard Satellite Scheduling for Maritime SurveillanceUbotica Demonstrates Autonomous Onboard Satellite Scheduling for Maritime Surveillance
    UniSQ Demonstrates Tomographic Spectrometer During KREPE-3 Re-Entry CampaignUniSQ Demonstrates Tomographic Spectrometer During KREPE-3 Re-Entry Campaign
    Orbital Sentry Develops Persistent Geostationary Infrared Sensor for Real-Time Wildfire DetectionOrbital Sentry Develops Persistent Geostationary Infrared Sensor for Real-Time Wildfire Detection
    NASA’s Swift Observatory Expected to Burn Up in Atmospheric Reentry Following Failed Commercial RescueNASA’s Swift Observatory Expected to Burn Up in Atmospheric Reentry Following Failed Commercial Rescue

Forrester Reports: Going Head to Head — SES and Intelsat

February 24, 2020


Chris Forrester

Another suite of missives from Intelsat were issued to the FCC on February 21 explaining where Intelsat stood on the CBA and the FCC’s decision to apportion proceeds from the upcoming auction in an equal split between Intelsat and SES, and the latter firm has let their disappointment regarding Intelsat’s actions be known, as related by journalist Chris Forrester at the Advanced Television infosite.

In one FCC filing, Intelsat pulling no punches, and said, “Nonetheless, on February 20, SES Americom Inc. (“SES”) filed a startling and incorrect Ex Parte document with the Commission, in which it relied on a defunct voluntary agreement and confidential audit report to advocate for a greater allocation of incentive payments. This is unfounded, and the willful misuse of confidential information and deliberate mischaracterization of such report before a federal agency, is indefensible.
     "Given the FCC’s decision not to pursue a private market-based approach, and instead to structure the clearing of the C-band through mandates, incentives, and reimbursements directed at each satellite operator in its individual capacity, SES’s invocation of a private agreement that was predicated on a completely different structure is legally irrelevant and factually unsupported."

Intelsat says it wants “at least” 60 percent of the revenue share.

Another separate filing to the FCC complains that the spectrum it (and SES and Telesat) is surrendering for auction is admitted by the FCC to be worth tens of billions of dollars, “with some parties submitting estimates as high as $77 billion”.

The company also argues that the FCC is wrong to consider its authority to decide in favor of an FCC-organized auction, stating that the FCC’s own rules only permits it to “modify” existing licenses and not to make fundamental changes to its licenses. “Forcing licensees to involuntarily relinquish more than half of the spectrum covered by their licenses, as well as to take on billions of dollars in accompanying relocation costs under a transition plan that has a number of unpredictable moving parts and potential payment clawbacks, cannot be fairly characterized as a mere “modification” to the licenses at issue,” said Intelsat. “In short, as the hundreds of megahertz and billions of dollars at stake make clear, along with the massive new risks and obligations FSS providers would shoulder under the proposed transition plans, the changes to existing licenses proposed in the Draft Order are too extensive to be considered mere “modifications” that the Commission can require even if the affected licensees do consent.”

Intelsat accuses the FCC of being “capricious” and “arbitrary” and “irrational” in its decision-making.

The satellite operator says the firm continues to support the FCC’s overall goal, but the Draft Order now on the table “cannot advance the FCC’s objectives in its current form”.

The FCC is expected to issue its final Order on February 28.

Certainly the gloves are definitely off, as far as SES is concerned, with its former partner in the C-Band Alliance (CBA).

In a last-minute filing to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), SES stated their disappointment by Intelsat’s last-minute attempt to renounce its commitments made to other CBA members and the Commission over the course of this proceeding, ‘in aid of a transparent and baseless attempt to capture a greater share of the proposed accelerated relocation payments.’  “In light of all that has been achieved to date, this sudden reversal in direction by Intelsat is indefensible.”

SES states that based on independent third-party studies “[the] undisputed facts conclusively show that Intelsat and SES deserve equal shares of any accelerated relocation payments.”

SES reminds the FCC of the structure and rationale behind the creation of the Alliance up to the issuing of the FCC’s draft proposals on February 7. “Since then, and in breach of its contractual commitments, Intelsat now seeks to deny the role of the CBA going forward.  It is ironic that, in the very filing in which it seeks to deny the ongoing relevance of the CBA, Intelsat relies on the CBA’s filings and plans as evidence of the timing and cost of clearing.”

SES says it rejects the assertion by Intelsat that ‘there will be no C-Band Alliance going forward,’ and stated the company believes there remains an important role for the CBA and that the CBA’s collaborative clearing plan is the most efficient path to clear the spectrum. “Intelsat has no right to unilaterally disband the CBA, and SES will hold Intelsat responsible under its commitments.  That said, SES is prepared to act on its own in the clearing process if necessary, while protecting its customers.”

Filed Under: Spectrum & Licensing

Primary Sidebar

Coverage

  • Missions & Constellations
  • Business & Finance
  • Military & Defense
  • Launch
  • Software Automation & Ground Systems
  • Government & Regulation
  • Services & Applications

Most Read Stories

  • SpaceX Acquires Grain Management’s 800 MHz Spectrum Portfolio to Launch Standalone Starlink Mobile Carrier
  • Amazon Leo Plans Prime Subscription Bundling to Challenge Starlink in Consumer Satellite Broadband Market
  • SpaceX Restricts Military Starshield Speeds in Ukraine, Disrupting Pentagon-Funded Tactical Drone Operations
  • SpaceX Requests FAA Approval for Up to 456 Starship Launches Annually at Starbase
  • Kratos Defense Demonstrates Multi-Vendor 5G Satellite Connectivity Using Virtualized OpenSpace Ground Platform

Secondary Sidebar

Footer

 

Satnews is a leading provider of satellite news, events, publications, research and other satellite industry information in both commercial and military enterprises worldwide.

Stories By Category

  • Business & Finance
  • Government & Regulation
  • Launch
  • Military & Defense
  • Missions & Constellations
  • Services & Applications
  • Software Automation & Ground Systems
  • Spectrum & Licensing
  • Startups & NewSpace Business

About Us

  • Leadership & Editorial Team
  • SatNews History
  • Free Satnews Subscription
  • SatNews Events
  • Magazines

Navigation

  • Latest Stories
  • Magazines
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Cookie & Privacy Policy for Satnews

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.
x
Sign up Now (For Free)
Access daily or weekly satellite news updates covering all aspects of the commercial and military satellite industry.
Invalid email address
Notify Me Regarding ( At least one ):
We value your privacy and will not sell or share your email or other information with any other company. You may also unsubscribe at anytime.

Click Here to see our full privacy policy.
Thanks for subscribing!